Location
- Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science
- Paul Smiths, NY
- Valley City State University
- Valley City, ND
Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science vs Valley City State University
Paul Smiths, NY · Valley City, ND · largest Scorecard gap: in-state tuition
Scorecard match plate
Pair NY:ND
MIXED-SECTOR · CROSS-STATE · ACCEPT-OPEN · NET-SPLIT · EARN-SPLIT · DEBT-SPLIT · COMPLETE-PAR · GAP-TUITION
- MIXED-SECTOR Mixed sector
- CROSS-STATE NY × ND
- ACCEPT-OPEN Open admission
- NET-SPLIT Net-price split
- EARN-SPLIT Earnings split
- DEBT-SPLIT Debt split
- COMPLETE-PAR Completion near-par
- GAP-TUITION Largest gap · In-State Tuition
Instrument codes from this pair's College Scorecard ownership, geography, acceptance, net price, earnings, debt, and completion, plus the ENROLL-1SIDE · modest · 2013–2023 decade-path stamp below, not a ranking or recommendation.
Decade path · College Scorecard
Only one enrollment path is a trend
ENROLL-1SIDE · modest · 2013–2023
Size changed directionally at one school over 2013–2023; the peer's series stays a range. Pair any selectivity note with that asymmetry before treating the two campuses as parallel growth stories.
- Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science: enrollment shrank -40.5% over 2013–2023; fitted -35 students/yr fitted, r² 0.94.
- Valley City State University: enrollment ranged 914–1,038 (2013–2023, 11 points) without a stable fitted direction.
- Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science: acceptance-rate path 2013–2023 stays non-directional here (r² 0.00).
- Valley City State University: acceptance-rate path 2013–2023 stays non-directional here (r² 0.30).
College Scorecard institution series; dollars are nominal. Direction claims require r² ≥ 0.40 on the fitted annual slope, otherwise the page reports the observed range. Descriptive history, not a recommendation.
Scorecard metrics
Type
- Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science
- Private Nonprofit
- Valley City State University
- Public
Undergraduate Enrollment
In-State Tuition
- Valley City State University
- $8,514
Out-of-State Tuition
- Valley City State University
- $13,544
Avg Net Price
- Valley City State University
- $11,890
Acceptance Rate
Median Earnings (6 yr)
- Valley City State University
- $45,820
Median Earnings (10 yr)
- Valley City State University
- $52,725
Median Debt at Graduation
- Valley City State University
- $20,369
Loan Repayment Rate (Completers)
Cards ordered by relative gap on this pair. Teal = better side.
| Metric | Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science Paul Smiths, NY | Valley City State University Valley City, ND |
|---|---|---|
| Location | Paul Smiths, NY | Valley City, ND |
| Type | Private Nonprofit | Public |
| Undergraduate Enrollment | 579 | 958 |
| In-State Tuition | $33,009 | $8,514 |
| Out-of-State Tuition | $33,009 | $13,544 |
| Avg Net Price | $26,683 | $11,890 |
| Acceptance Rate | 76.5% | 99.1% |
| Median Earnings (6 yr) | $38,325 | $45,820 |
| Median Earnings (10 yr) | $46,145 | $52,725 |
| Median Debt at Graduation | $22,750 | $20,369 |
| Loan Repayment Rate (Completers) | 81.6% | 88.8% |
Largest gaps: Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science vs Valley City State University
- IN-STATE-TUITION Valley City State University leads on in-state tuition ($8,514 vs $33,009 at Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science)
- OUT-OF-STATE-TUITI Valley City State University leads on out-of-state tuition ($13,544 vs $33,009 at Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science)
- AVG-NET-PRICE Valley City State University leads on avg net price ($11,890 vs $26,683 at Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science)
Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science profile · Valley City State University profile · Compare other colleges
In-State Tuition and other Scorecard questions
On in-state tuition, who leads between Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science and Valley City State University?▼
Valley City State University leads on in-state tuition at $8,514 versus $33,009 at Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science. Source: U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard.
On out-of-state tuition, who leads between Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science and Valley City State University?▼
Valley City State University leads on out-of-state tuition at $13,544 versus $33,009 at Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science. Source: U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard.
On avg net price, who leads between Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science and Valley City State University?▼
Valley City State University leads on avg net price at $11,890 versus $26,683 at Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science. Source: U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard.
Source: U.S. Department of Education, College Scorecard College Scorecard institution outcomes (earnings, completion, debt); in-state tuition focus for this pair · 2025